Or as my Star Wars loving friends are apt to say:
“May The 4th Be With You!”
I’m pecking this out on my laptop at the Greensboro, NC airport. Dang, 3:45am came early this morning --- and it hit me as I was drifting off to sleep last night that I didn’t put anything in the blog queue for this morning!
No worries….I have an hour until my flight so I can sit here, go through some show photos from last week’s Vermont Quilt Festival and occupy myself until it is time to board.
As often happens with really early morning posts – my mind starts to wander and ponder about many things.
I have come to realize that I would never make a great quilt judge. Some of the judging I just do NOT understand.
I know it is all about the numbers, and how things add up on "paper". But some things I just have to go with my heart on.
And what I say isn’t “against” any one’s quilt or the judges themselves ---it’s just how I feel.
There was a quilt that won “best reproduction quilt” or something like that. Big award. Lots of applause at the awards ceremony. I hadn’t seen the quilt yet, but when we were allowed into the show and I saw the quilt….all I could see was that yes, it was a beautiful “civil war” array of fabrics, but that the quilting itself was so over the top and the quilt itself so stiff that it in no way represented to me what a civil war era made quilt would look like.
It was “just this short” of having crystals glued to it. And there was a lot of discussion about how many quilts had crystals glued to them, and I hope it is a fad that will go away ----but that’s a subject for another time.
((See, I told you, I would make a BAD quilt judge!))
Too much is too much is too much. I’m a quilter who makes quilts to cover the people I love. Crystals are not part of the equation, and neither is over-the top machine quilting –especially when it comes to a reproduction quilt. How would that Quiltmkaer have quilted her quilt in 1865? That’s what I want to see if it is a true reproduction.
I want to share with you my favorite quilt of the whole show ----it is named “Oh My Stars” by Sue Freeland of Hanesport, NJ. It's perfect to share for 4th of July!
I loved this quilt in its complicated simplicity!
All of this close quilting is done by hand. The quilt has a softness that an overly machine quilted quilt is just not going to have. To me --- this is more in keeping with the time period of a civil war era quilt than any amount of machine micro-stippling and over-feathering can give.
I adore the close diagonal quilting! And the curved design quilted over the star blocks to add another dimension to them. what a labor of love!
((Look Ma! No Crystals!))
The quilting found its way into the border to enhance the flying geese.
My favorite element! The zig zag lines in the open areas of the border.
What great texture!
Here is another shot showing that great border cable with 5 lines ((FIVE LINES!)) of hand quilting!
While I was standing there photographing the quilt, the maker happened to come by and I was privileged to talk to her, to tell her my feelings. It was wonderful that her quilt was recognized as worthy enough for a second place ribbon.
If I were a judge, I probably would have pushed it higher than that. In my book, this IS a blue ribbon quilt ---it got my viewers choice vote! It was quilted to match the era and style that the maker was wanting to capture.
Have a great 4th of July everyone! I’m off to Chicago to go meet my son at his gate – and then we are off for our Idaho adventure.
Morning, Bonnie! Happy 4th! That reproduction stars quilt of Sue Freeland's is truly lovely. I love stars and to have three stacked up in themselves is just over the top in my book! Kudos to Sue for her design. Have a safe flight and great time in Idaho.
ReplyDeleteJune momabeel@rochester.rr.com
As long as there are human judges and judged quilt competitions this subject will be one open for discussion. The quilt you shared is stunning, well deserving of a ribbon! Enjoy your Idaho adventure... that is one of the states on my bucket list.
ReplyDeleteHappy 4th and safe travels, Bonnie. To celebrate this day, I want to share a picture of a quilt from the Columbus Quilt Show called America, Let it Shine made by Sherry Reynolds. It had a sparkle for every word in the constitution. See it on my blog at http://gladysgab.blogspot.com/2012/06/columbus-quilt-show.html
ReplyDeleteI love to meet the quilters! It's wonderful when the quilter can attend the show and be with their quilts, answer questions, and inspire us all! P.S. I've heard that the judges are always following the system given them by the show organizers, and they don't always like that system! The only ones they get to pick that the like best if Judge's Choice. (And we get to pick Viewer's Choice.) But to me, it's not all about the ribbons. If people didn't sent their quilts, we wouldn't have shows at all.
ReplyDeleteI loved that quilt too, Bonnie, it was so beautiful! I was amazed that it was hand quilted, and truly disappointed that it only won second prize. I also agree with you about the over abundance of crystals in quilts these days. I do love me some sparkle - but I only feel it is appropriate in wall hangings. I think it is impractical to put them on bed quilts. Oh well, we all have different tastes I guess!
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for sharing this gorgeous quilt! I couldn't agree with you more that this quilt deserved a blue ribbon. We're so lucky to have Sue as president of our guild. She and her quilts are an inspiration to all of us.
ReplyDeleteBonnie - I couldn't agree with you more --- this one is gorgeous in the true sense of the word, and deserving of every award I can think of.
ReplyDeleteI honestly do not understand what judges want! At shows, there is such a wonderful array of REAL QUILTS, and they are passed by. Somehow, in an odd and even unknowing way, judges have fallen into the commerical end of quilting...deeply. If you use the right fabric, in the newest design artsy artsy, then you are awarded. If you quilt from the heart, and even into your own soul, you can rest assured the real quilters are going to love your quilt. But the judges are down right guaranteed to pass it by. OK, enough of my soapbox rants on this subject lol.
Thanks once again for sharing with us all you do. Have a special 4th, and relax... nap, walk and just plain ejoy.
Smiles,
JulieinTN
Oh yeah! Love this quilt! Thanks for sharing it with us and have a happy 4th!
ReplyDeleteCrystals on quilts? I dont thin I can even picture that? I agree with judging. I show quilts to share them. My freestyle patterns and piecing and organic quilting never seem to stand up to the judging process. I also discount judging because it only looks at a finished product with out the accompanied story behind the inspiration and making of the quilt.
ReplyDeleteThis quilt is wonderful and the hand quilting...amazing! I love tiny hand quilting and this is really a treasure - thanks for sharing! Have a great time with your family and Happy 4th to you!
ReplyDeleteWhat a beautiful quilt! I agree with your assessment. Excellent workmanship with the period of the quilt in mind. Thanks for sharing. Enjoy your family time and of course, Sisters. Looking forward to hearing all about it! Happy 4th!
ReplyDeleteI agree that it is a beautiful quilt. I admire all the hand quilting. A lot of work but so worth it on this quilt.
ReplyDeleteVery beautiful quilt! I am impressed with the hand quilting.
ReplyDeleteI whole heartedly agree with you about the quilts you talked about!!! I am a traditional quilter and wish to remain TRADITIONAL. The quilt with all of the hand quilting is gorgeaous! I am sooooo glad you posted your post. I wish more people felt the way you do. Thanks for your honest opinions!
ReplyDeleteI agree with you! Save the crystal for wine! SMILE. Your number one fan again :)
ReplyDeleteBeautiful quilt ... would have loved to have seen it in person. Agree with you about crystals; I just don't see how they fit in with quilting and am actually "turned off" of a quilt when I see them (and they seem to be a fad appearing more frequently at shows). Traditional is my middle name ... love scrappy, traditional and quality handwork. Travel safe; say hello to my former "hometown" (Chicago) and enjoy the family time ... it is precious!
ReplyDeleteLovely quilt. Thank you so much for sharing. I can't help but wonder what the crystal quilts will look like 100 years from now. But you know this lovely Civil War reproduction will stand the test of time.
ReplyDeleteAt one point in my life, I used to show pekingese. The breeders were getting into these fluffy, cotton candy coats... which is not in line with the breed standard. A breeder I greatly admired published an article in which he said... "sufficient is enough, and enough is enough." I think this applies to quilting (as well as many other things in life). A quilt doesn't need so much quilting that it stands on its own. I agree with you... I want my quilts to be loved and cuddled.
This IS a great quilt!! I love em all....even the over-quilted, bling-ed out ones. I tend to make traditional quilts but still like art quilts. There's room for everyone. And the trends keep cycling around, so, it's all good!
ReplyDeleteLori in VA
Actually May the 4th, really is on May 4th. I'm not a Star Wars fan, never saw a movie, but I'm just corny like that. Hope you have a fabulous 4th. I hope to get some quilting in today. I have been so busy that I've had no time. Maybe seeing your pics will motivate me to get a lot accomplished today, so I have some free time!
ReplyDeleteI couldn't agree more that this is a lovely quilt deserving of a blue ribbon. The beautiful patchwork design is greatly enhanced by the fantastic hand quilting - it a wonderful example of a reproduction quilt! I am also lucky enough to be a member of Sue's quilt guild in New Jersey! This quilt won Viewer's Choice at our guild's 2011 quilt show, and another of her hand quilted quilts won Viewer's Choice at our 2009 show. Her work is a great inspiration to us all! Thanks!
ReplyDeleteSaw this quilt on Regan's blog and loved it. Thanks for the detailed shots and the smiling face of its maker. As for your thoughts--Amen.
ReplyDeleteI saw a quilt called "super stars" on another blog from the Vermont show and maker stated she just wanted the stars to sparkle so she added crystals.
ReplyDeleteAs long as the public applauds it the judges will reward it. Is there a difference between a show quilt and a usable quilt?
I don't understand any of it. I often go to a show and stand there and say "really?" when I see ribbons galore hanging on a quilt. Like you I would have a whole different winner for my ribbons :0)
Happy sewing,
Have a wonderful family holiday with your loved ones.
Happy 4th! And safe travels! Enjoy the family! Thank you so much for sharing that gorgeous quilt. I am so glad you got to meet the quilter who made it. And glad you took her picture standing in front of it, it helped to really appreciate how big it is and with such beautiful quilting.
ReplyDeleteWhat a beautiful quilt! And I'm sure the maker was delighted with your love for it too. I am just absolutely AMAZED at the hand quilting. To me that makes it a Blue Ribbon quilt without question!
ReplyDeleteWow that is truely a wonderful quilt. I agree would be my favorite quilt of the show. I agree less machine quilting is much more attractive. Handquilting is still traditionally the best.Thank you for sharing. Have a safe trip home.
ReplyDeleteHi Bonnie, you've said things here that I've been afraid to say to fellow guild members because I would have appeared snarky and bitchy.But it's all true. If the civil war quilt was to be a true reproduction then it should have had simple tasteful quilting suitable to the time period.
ReplyDeleteI also hate crystals-period- But I am a art quilter and I embellish my wall quilts. I use buttons and beads, ricrac, etc, but this glued on crystal fad drives me nuts!!
Nina M. www.fiberwhimsys.wordpress.com
I admire good machine quilting , but not when there's more thread than fabric,and the whole thing could stand on it's own. A bed quilt is meant for comfort and drapability- not stiff as a board.
Oh and you didn't mention putting a photo on fabric and then covering it with thread.I see so many prizes given to this type of quilt. There is no great feat in that. If you want to thread paint - then draw your own picture and shade in the colors.Shudder.
Bonnie,
ReplyDeleteI have followed you for years now but never commented. You are always right on my wavelength. I used a leader/ ender before i heard of you but it wasn't a productive one. You have multiplied my quilts and as I am a scrap quilter it works wonderfully.
Today you zinged it right there! I am a long arm quilter (not in your league) and I like to see quilts done"gently". Crystals and intense quilting are good for art quilts. That's not for me. I love vintage designs and highly respect hand quilting-my hands just won't allow it!
The star quilt is wonderful!
Thanks for speaking out.
Hope you pain recedes and your trip is a success.
I watch your calendar to see
if you're close to me!
NJ
I recently used 870 crystals...but on my daughter's wedding dress. not a quilt. I might use some of the leftovers if i ever make a wall hanging, but I am definitely in the camp of those who make quilts to be used, and I can't imagine snuggling with a crystal!
ReplyDeleteGeorgeous star quilt. Wonderfully done--creative hand quilting. I have never seen zigzag hand quiltingbefore. Very impressive use of qulting in a simple star pattern quilt. It enhances and compliments the blocks. Thank you for sharing the close-ups. Thank you to the quiltmaker for entering the quilt in the show for others to see. Blue Ribbon Quilt in my opinion!
ReplyDeleteArdis
Wonderful picture of the hand quilting - thanks Bonnie! I was wondering if she did the hand quilting on a frame or a lap hoop? I really like the idea of a frame sitting in my room waiting for me to add a few stitches.... I have a hoop and find it cumbersome sometimes. ( hehjude53@hotmail.com )
ReplyDeleteThanks! Happy 4th!
I agree with your crystals on quilts comment. There seems to be more "fiber artists" at quilt shows than quilters. And I ask my machine quilter to quilt less so the quilt will be drape-able over the body and not stiff (able to stand up on its own). I love the border cable and hand quilting in the beautiful quilt you shared. I also noticed the thin dark border pieces that seem to really frame the quilt. It was wonderful to see a photo of the maker as well. Thanks for sharing! Happy 4th and family time, and Sister, OR time!
ReplyDeleteI'm with you on the crystals! And love the star quilt here. It really is a show piece reflecting an era.
ReplyDeleteI'm not fond of crystals either. It's not so much that they don't belong on bed quilts - which they don't. I don't think many of those show quilts are adorning beds, anyway. I'm just not a very "blingy" kind of girl. I'm not terribly traditional either, but that's the wonderful thing about quilting - there's something for every one. Lois
ReplyDeleteSue's Oh My Stars quilt is gorgeous! I've never seen zig-zag hand quilting before & this is spectacular! And 5 lines of curves in the border, Oh wow! Wish I lived closer to see more of Sue's inspiring quilts. Almost makes me want to try handquilting, but then I'm afraid I'd never finish anything.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing Bonnie! Enjoy your time with family & at Sisters. Hope you get some relief from you sciatica.
Excellent post and I totally agree with your opinion. Oh My Stars is a beautiful quilt. Enjoy your vacation!
ReplyDeleteI wonder if quilt show organizers shouldn't take a quip from TV?
ReplyDeleteHow about Civil War Makeovers?
There one could 'make over' the whole concept.
I agree with you on your choice. I really abhor machine quilted quilts that look like "road kill"--the corners curl up they are so heavily quilted. Needless to say, I am a hand quilter. It takes a long time but well worth it in the long run. When you place a hand-quilted quilt over your body, it clings to you,hugs you. And all of my quilts are to use (exception of course, wall-size.)
ReplyDeleteI also love making your scrap quilts.
Yep, Bonnie, I too totally agree. Quilt shows have gone to the artsy stuff which is ok but should be separate from "real" usable quilts. While you're enjoying your family, if you happen to see any Star TREK fabric, let me know! trying to make a quilt for a nephew who loves all the Star Trek shows.
ReplyDeleteCRYSTALS...really !!! on quilts to use & cuddle up in !!!! that "fad" doesn't seem to have reached over here yet ( Australia) at least not that I've seen :( hope it stays your side of "the pond " lol
ReplyDeleteI agree totally on your thought here about "overly quilted" quilts. I would say we've reached an era where the ability to micro quilt every inch of a quilt has gone too far. This quilt is exactly what a reproduction quilt should be. What beautiful piecing, colors and quilting.
ReplyDelete